Discover more from Elliott’s notebook
The Crosstab Weekly Newsletter 📊 October 21, 2018
Unexpected "blue wave" seats and 💰💰Democratic cash💰💰💰. + Swing voters and disenfranchisement
Welcome! I’m G. Elliott Morris, data journalist at The Economistand blogger of polls, elections, and political science. Happy Sunday! Here’s my weekly newsletter with links to what I’ve been reading and writing that puts the news in context with public opinion polls, political science, other data (some “big,” some small) and looks briefly at the week ahead. Let’s jump right in! Feedback? Drop me a line or just respond to this email.
This newsletter is made possible by supporters on Patreon. A special thanks to those who pledge the top two tiers is written in the endnotes. If you enjoy my personal newsletter and want it to continue, consider a monthly subscription for early access and regular blogging for just $2.
This Week's Big Question
What does a wide playing field portend for the House midterms?
Democrats have slim chances to win a large number of Republican-held seats. Just look at the number of Likely or Lean Republican seats in my forecasts: According to my number-crunching, there are 95 Republican-held seats that are forecast to be won by less than 10 points by either party, but just 9 Democratic-held seats in the same category.
This wide, 100-seat playing field creates the chance that Democrats win a few fluke upsets in their path to a House majority. For fun, here are what some of those fluke wins would look like (PS: You can simulate your own wacky maps using my data which has been put to great use at 270towin.com):
In this map, Democrats win Montana’s at-large district (they have a 31% chance today) Michigan’s 1st (a 17% chance) and 7th (25%), North Carolina’s 8th (21%), etc. The point being: all of these districts are projected to be Republican holds, but due to the nature of probability Democrats could easily win them.
Odds are that Democrats will win some unexpected seats. Keep in mind the this doesn’t guarantee a Democratic victory; they have just a 76% chance of doing so, per my forecast, and an 85% chance in the 538 model (which was tracking similarly unless the recent about of tsunami Dem wave fundraising reports). With 15 days left until the midterms, in which of these seats do you think the Democrats or Republicans will win unexpected victories?
Politics and Election Data
WITH just 20 days left until the mid-term elections that will determine the fate of Donald Trump’s legislative agenda and possibly his presidency, national polls give the Democrats a robust lead of around eight percentage points.
After President Trump’s popularity on social media helped propel him to an upset victory in 2016, Democrats vowed to catch up. Two years later, their efforts appear to be paying off.
Polls show enthusiasm surging in many mostly white suburban districts, but less so among young and nonwhite voters.
Solving a paradox in the forecast.
A thread on @WholeFoods and elections: @Redistrict recently wrote that Dems will perform the best in areas that are geographically close to Whole Foods (WF). I decided to map/calculate the # of Whole Foods by congressional district to test his theory on WF and elections (1/9) https://t.co/9fw6qTjOZZ
12:19 PM - 21 Oct 2018
Everybody knows that young Americans don’t tend to go to the polls. But data shows steep midterm turnout declines among 30-, 40- and 50-somethings, too.
Hey folks - updated The Spreadsheet this weekend! Now featuring forecasts from @538, @0ptimusPredicts, @gelliottmorris, @databyler and newly added models from @rudnicknoah and @ForecasterEnten. (In addition to expert ratings and the @PredicIt markets) https://t.co/iTraMmtVdx
4:09 PM - 21 Oct 2018
Neither party should feel too confident in what polls show right now.
Other Data and Cool Work
PROFESSIONAL success, we are often told, is won through natural talent, hard work, and determination. But luck also plays a part. Sometimes this is manifested in the booms and busts of the business cycle.
The tweets include Russia’s consistent efforts to disparage Hillary Clinton during the 2016 campaign.
Political Science & Survey Research
More Republicans are citing Democrats as a reason for their congressional vote.
A candidate’s conundrum: Many independent voters are repelled by the partisan appeals that spur the party faithful to the polls.
“Is Your Representative a Grandstander? Measuring Message Politics in Committee Hearings” by Ju Yeon (Julia) Park:
“This paper measures a “grandstanding score” for each statement that committee members make based on its intensity of opinion-giving and identifies which types of members of Congress and committees tend to use hearings to make their points. I argue that committee members grandstand in hearings to offset their limited legislative power. My findings suggest that such grandstanding behavior is more common among minority members under a unified government, and non-chair members of powerful committees, and in committees with jurisdiction over policies that the president wields primary power, such as foreign affairs and national security.”
What I'm Reading and Working On
A Special Thank-you Note to Patrons
My weekly newsletter is supported by generous patrons who give monthly to my blog, including these individuals who have pledged especially charitable contributions:
Ellen, Christopher, Robert, Robert, Mark, laura, Katy, Joshua, Joshua, Edward, Ed, David, Daniel, Dan, Christina, Carol, Cameron, Calvin, Ben, Alden, and Walter
Uri, Tal, Sandeep, Nik, Mark, Malcolm, Krishan, Josh, Joseph, Jon, Hunter, Guillermo, Gail, Fred, Erik, Eric, David, Darren, Darcy, Daniel, Brett, Bob, Ben, and Andrew
Like the newsletter and want to help keep it going? Subscribe today on Patreon for access to private posts and other perks.